ALNAP Report “What’s Missing”: Understanding Urban Context to Improve Response

3.May.2018
By JIPS
Related Topics: Urban

Humanitarian and development practitioners generally accept that programs, policies, and processes need to be “context-specific” to reach their goals. With more and more crises impacting urban contexts, this conundrum is taking on a distinctly urban flavour. But what does context actually mean, and which tools are best suited to help us make our action ‘context-specific’? The much-anticipated report “What’s missing? Adding context to the urban response toolbox” sets out to answer these questions.

It is the result of a two-year research and consultation process with a wide array of practitioners and organisations, including an initial learning event that we attended in 2017 to share our knowledge on tools. As JIPS we engaged throughout the process by contributing our expertise working on profiling urban displacement situations. The launch event organised by the Active Learning Network for Accountability and Performance in Humanitarian Action (ALNAP) in March in Beirut was a great opportunity to discuss the report and remaining questions.

What is context and why should we take it into account?

The ALNAP report defines context as “the environment and circumstances within which something happens and which can help explain it”. This refers to occurrences that are wider in scope than the singular event leading to a humanitarian crisis: it includes the interconnected web of events that happened before the crisis, as well as the events that are likely to happen after.

Understanding the “bigger picture” helps to explain why disastrous events can have the effect they have. As Leah Campbell (ALNAP) says, “context gives meaning to what has happened and helps explain its significance“. If we ignore the context and focus solely on the immediate impact of a disaster, conflict or human rights violations (as humanitarian action has been trained to do for decades), we fail to consider the elements that mitigate or amplify this impact, and are therefore less able to complement or prevent those outcomes.

 

Core tools highlighted include focus on displacement and profiling

To us at JIPS, we strive to make sure profiling analysis is relevant for decision-makers, practitioners and affected communities by working with partners to ensure methods used are adapted for context realities. This report therefore fills a major gap by tackling the fundamental question on how to understand a context well enough in order to make a data collection process “context-specific”. It demonstrates that relevant processes and programs require a clear understanding of the dynamics of a city, and that obtaining this understanding is in fact feasible.

Understanding the wider context is particularly relevant in urban displacement settings. As emphasised by the recently published Durable Solutions Analysis Guide, it is important to look at whether the context creates additional challenges for displaced populations compared with non-displaced communities living in that same place (such as services provided without discrimination due to the displacement status).

The report reviews a set of 25 tools that can help practitioners in understanding complex urban systems. Of the various tools reviewed, several focus specifically on displacement:

  • Displacement profiling: supported and refined by JIPS, it aims to create a comprehensive overview of a displacement situation, putting collaboration of all relevant stakeholders, including national and local authorities, at its centre (find out more on the JET and check out our Guidance for Urban Displacement Profiling as well).
  • Settlement-based assessments: currently being piloted by IMPACT Initiatives, it aims to support relevant area-based responses in different districts of a city, and is particularly used to help understand services and space. It can be used at the city and neighbourhood level.
  • Neighbourhood and City Profiles: created by UN-Habitat Lebanon, these explore a range of contextual aspects and focus especially on space.
  • Urban Context Analysis Toolkit: developed by the International Rescue Committee (IRC), this tool allows for a better understanding of the dynamics going on in an urban context by analysing political, economic, social, infrastructural and spatial systems.

No ‘one tool fits all’ solution

All of these tools combine, in one way or another, an analysis of the context with a deeper dive into the situation of the displaced populations. Looking at the differences, these mostly rely on the different analytical angles used, the time required for their implementation (ranging from a few weeks to several months), their specific focus areas, and the resources required for implementation.

Just as context varies, so do the needs for an analysis of the context; therefore, there is no ‘one-tool-fits-all’ answer. In fact, different elements from different tools such as those listed above could be combined to enrich a process. Taking the time to clarify the main objectives of the analysis, such as identifying the key questions and the level of detail needed, as well as the time and resources available, will help in assessing how to design a process that responds best to those objectives.

 

Next steps: from learning to action

The Learning Exchange brought together urban practitioners from humanitarian and development sectors, including from INGOs such as World Vision, Save the Children, and Concern Worldwide, UN agencies such as UNICEF and UN-Habitat, and academic institutions like the Institute for Global Prosperity and Relief Centre of the University College of London (UCL). This diverse participation enabled discussion around the use of the report by different audiences. Concrete suggestions included greater dissemination to guide people through the concepts (including a webinar taking place on May 8), and making it more accessible to practitioners by creating an interactive platform to match information needs to the tools reviewed in the report.

This report will serve as an important resource, as the Global Alliance for Urban Crises seeks to guide practitioners to further strengthen humanitarian response and coordination in the coming year, making sure to reflect the key dimensions of the urban context throughout.

As the discussions at the learning event showed, however, a number of questions still remain, including:

  • Which tools work for understanding context, and which don’t? Participants highlighted the need to go a step beyond this comprehensive review to evaluate the impact and usefulness of these tools (also linked to the fact that many of them were only launched recently and have only been used by one organisation).
  • How can we better understand the interconnectedness between the different aspects of context? None of the tools fully answer this question. JIPS is exploring this further through its work with partners in the Urban Analysis Network – Syria (UrbAN-S) project. The partners are developing a framework for assessing the links between the dimensions of the urban context to help prioritise interventions in a city.

As agreed by the participants to the Beirut Learning Exchange, a new phase of research, focused on evaluating the impact of the tools and their usefulness in response planning would be an asset to the humanitarian and development community as a whole. In the upcoming months, organisations such as the members of the Global Alliance for Urban Crises, will help disseminate the report, demonstrate its relevance for global initiatives, and incorporate the tools more and more into their work in the field.

Join us at these upcoming events

  • Partner Event
    26 Mar 19 - 28 Mar 19

    9th Meeting of the Inter-Agency and Expert Group on SDG Indicators (IAEG-SDGs)

Let's stay in touch

Email Format

JIPS – Joint IDP Profiling Service will use the information you provide on this form to send you email updates (usually once a month) about our activities.

You can change your mind at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting us at info@JIPS.org. We will treat your information with respect and will never share it with, or sell it to, others. By clicking 'SUBSCRIBE', you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking 'SUBSCRIBE' to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices here.

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn More